Most reliable for their age
First-time MOT pass rate against the average for cars the same age
- 1 Porsche 911 +21 pts88% vs 67%
- 2 Mercedes-Benz SLK +9 pts72% vs 62%
- 3 BMW 520 +9 pts77% vs 68%
- 4 Mazda MX-5 +9 pts74% vs 65%
- 5 Audi TT +9 pts76% vs 67%
- 6 Land Rover Range Rover +9 pts78% vs 69%
- 7 Audi A6 +8 pts79% vs 71%
- 8 Land Rover Range Rover Sport +8 pts80% vs 72%
- 9 BMW X5 +8 pts79% vs 72%
- 10 BMW 3 Series +7 pts72% vs 65%
Least reliable for their age
The same comparison, from the bottom
- 1 Citroen DS3 −15 pts52% vs 67%
- 2 Renault Clio −11 pts57% vs 68%
- 3 Renault Megane −11 pts54% vs 65%
- 4 Citroen C4 −10 pts61% vs 71%
- 5 Peugeot 207 −9 pts50% vs 60%
- 6 Dacia Sandero −9 pts69% vs 79%
- 7 Dacia Duster −8 pts72% vs 80%
- 8 Fiat Punto −6 pts55% vs 62%
- 9 Peugeot 308 −6 pts64% vs 70%
- 10 Vauxhall Mokka −6 pts71% vs 77%
Lists include models with at least 50,000 first MOT tests in 2024. Points are the gap between a model’s first-time pass rate and the average for cars the same age: 88% against 67% is +21 points.
How it works
- Every MOT counts. We use the DVSA’s record of every MOT test in Great Britain, not a survey of owners.
- First tests only. A pass means the car passed at the first attempt, with nothing failed or fixed on the spot.
- Fair on age. Older cars fail more, so each model is compared with all cars of the same age.