wrenchmark

Is that used car reliable?

Real MOT results for every popular car, from 33.1 million first MOT tests in 2024.

Most reliable for their age

First-time MOT pass rate against the average for cars the same age

  1. 1 Porsche 911 +21 pts88% vs 67%
  2. 2 Mercedes-Benz SLK +9 pts72% vs 62%
  3. 3 BMW 520 +9 pts77% vs 68%
  4. 4 Mazda MX-5 +9 pts74% vs 65%
  5. 5 Audi TT +9 pts76% vs 67%
  6. 6 Land Rover Range Rover +9 pts78% vs 69%
  7. 7 Audi A6 +8 pts79% vs 71%
  8. 8 Land Rover Range Rover Sport +8 pts80% vs 72%
  9. 9 BMW X5 +8 pts79% vs 72%
  10. 10 BMW 3 Series +7 pts72% vs 65%

Least reliable for their age

The same comparison, from the bottom

  1. 1 Citroen DS3 −15 pts52% vs 67%
  2. 2 Renault Clio −11 pts57% vs 68%
  3. 3 Renault Megane −11 pts54% vs 65%
  4. 4 Citroen C4 −10 pts61% vs 71%
  5. 5 Peugeot 207 −9 pts50% vs 60%
  6. 6 Dacia Sandero −9 pts69% vs 79%
  7. 7 Dacia Duster −8 pts72% vs 80%
  8. 8 Fiat Punto −6 pts55% vs 62%
  9. 9 Peugeot 308 −6 pts64% vs 70%
  10. 10 Vauxhall Mokka −6 pts71% vs 77%

Lists include models with at least 50,000 first MOT tests in 2024. Points are the gap between a model’s first-time pass rate and the average for cars the same age: 88% against 67% is +21 points.

How it works

  1. Every MOT counts. We use the DVSA’s record of every MOT test in Great Britain, not a survey of owners.
  2. First tests only. A pass means the car passed at the first attempt, with nothing failed or fixed on the spot.
  3. Fair on age. Older cars fail more, so each model is compared with all cars of the same age.

Browse by make